Caraway claims its food storage containers are airtight, non-toxic, and stain-proof.
But are these claims valid? Are these containers worth buying?
In this review, I break down the pros and cons of the Caraway food storage set. You’ll learn about these containers’ materials, function, durability, design, and more.
Use the links below to navigate the review:
- Caraway Food Storage Review: Key Takeaways
- Video Review
- Pros of the Caraway Food Storage Set
- Cons of the Caraway Food Storage Set
- Bottom Line: Is the Caraway Food Storage Set Worth Buying?
Caraway Food Storage Review: Key Takeaways
If you’re in a rush, here are the key takeaways of this Caraway food storage review.
Caraway Food Storage Set Pros
- Non-Toxic: These containers are made of borosilicate glass with a sand-derived ceramic coating. They are completely non-toxic and safe for your health.
- Colorful: They’re available in various colors, including cream, sage, gray, mist, navy, and perracotta.
- Versatile: You can use them in the fridge, freezer, oven, and microwave.
- Airtight: My testing confirmed that their airtight seal ensures that your food remains fresh.
- Stain-Proof: They are stain-proof, maintaining their appearance even after storing colorful food items like tomato sauce or chili.
- Easy to Clean: Easy to clean, thanks to a smooth ceramic coating that prevents food from sticking.
- Easy to Store: It comes with three magnetic storage organizers, making them easy to store and keep in order.
Caraway Food Storage Set Cons
- Difficult to Open: Opening the containers requires considerable force due to the tight seal.
- Heavy: Their thick glass bodies make them significantly heavier than similar-sized plastic containers.
- Not for Liquids: You can’t use them to store liquids (especially on the go) due to a potential seal failure leading to leaks.
- Not See-Through: The containers’ opaque sidewalls prevent you from identifying the contents unless viewed from the top.
- Breakable: Like any glass product, these containers are prone to shattering if dropped.
- Expensive: Compared to other food storage solutions in the market, Caraway’s food storage set is on the expensive side.
Caraway food storage containers are expensive but non-toxic, colorful, versatile, airtight, and stain-proof. If you’re looking for well-designed containers to store and reheat food and you have the budget, Caraway is a great option. You can buy this set or individual pieces on CarawayHome.com and Amazon.
Rubbermaid Brilliance is the best alternative (view on Amazon).
Watch me break down the pros and cons of the Caraway food storage set in this quick video.
Pros of the Caraway Food Storage Set
I’ve been using the Caraway food storage set for several months. Here’s a breakdown of the key advantages of these containers.
The first thing you need to know about this set is that it’s 100% non-toxic.
These containers do not contain heavy metals, PFOA, lead, or other substances that could potentially endanger your health.
Caraway food storage containers are made of borosilicate glass, a material known for its superior durability and resistance to extreme temperature changes. The borosilicate glass is coated with a natural sand-based ceramic coating.
The lids of the Caraway food storage containers are made from tempered glass. Silicone edges are added to the lids to create a secure seal, further ensuring the freshness and safety of the food stored inside.
Caraway food storage containers aren’t just non-toxic; they’re also aesthetically pleasing. Unlike typical glass or plastic containers that might look bland, Caraway brings color and style into your kitchen.
The inside of these containers is a light gray. On the outside, you’ve got choices.
There’s the classic cream, a calming sage, a neutral gray, a soft mist, and a dark navy (pictured below). And then there’s perracotta — a mix between pink and orange — that adds a touch of fun and vibrancy.
If you’re familiar with Caraway cookware (see my review), you know they pay attention to the aesthetics as much as the functionality of their products.
Each time you reach for a container, you’ll appreciate not only the quality but also the thoughtfulness in design.
These containers are designed to be more than just a storage solution. They’re a practical companion for various cooking and storage needs.
They’re not only safe in the fridge and freezer, but you can also use them without the lids in the oven and microwave.
You can store your leftover casserole in the fridge and then heat it directly in the oven or microwave—no need to transfer it to another dish.
Plastic containers can’t be used in the oven, and some aren’t safe in the microwave.
Caraway claims its food storage containers are airtight, which is essential for keeping your food fresh. But does this claim hold up in practice?
To find out, I submerged the containers in water. At first, seeing some bubbles around the rubber seal, I was skeptical about its airtight claim.
But after closer observation, I realized that these bubbles were not from air leaking out but from water circulating the rubber seal.
When I removed the lid, some of those water droplets splashed into the container, but none leaked inside the containers when submerged.
So, yes, Caraway’s food storage containers live up to their promise of being airtight and keeping your food fresh.
Have you ever noticed how plastic containers turn red after you’ve stored tomato sauce or chili in them? With Caraway’s food storage containers, this isn’t a problem.
I tested this feature by storing tomato sauce in a Caraway container for several days and using the container to heat the sauce in the microwave.
Most containers would show signs of staining and discoloration, but the Caraway container remained as pristine as before.
Our Favorite Products in One Convenient Place
Want to see all the products we recommend in one convenient place? Visit the Prudent Reviews Amazon shop to browse a handpicked selection of our favorite cookware, kitchen knives, appliances, and more.
As an Amazon Associate Prudent Reviews earns from qualifying purchases.
No matter what you store, whether it’s marinara sauce, chili, curry, or beetroot salad, your Caraway food storage container will continue to look like new.
Caraway food storage containers are not only stain-free but also a breeze to clean.
Their ceramic coating provides a smooth surface, ensuring food doesn’t cling to the sides. You don’t have to scrub hard or soak them for hours to get them clean. Simply rinse, and you’re good to go.
Each set comes with three magnetic storage organizers, creating a neat and tidy storage system.
Whether you place them on your kitchen counter or tuck them away inside your cabinets, these organizers keep your containers in order.
If you’re short on space, Caraway containers are stackable. So even without using the organizers, you can easily pile them up in a way that takes up minimal room.
Cons of the Caraway Food Storage Set
Despite their benefits, the Caraway containers aren’t without faults. Let’s examine these drawbacks so you know what to expect.
The design incorporates an impressively tight seal, essential for maintaining the freshness and quality of the food inside. However, it does mean you’ll need to exert substantial force to pry the lid off.
If you have arthritis or lack strength in your hands or wrists, this may be a dealbreaker.
The weight of Caraway’s containers is another factor that might catch you off guard.
Their thick glass bodies significantly increase their weight. Take the small square container, for example. It alone weighs an impressive 26 ounces (1.6 pounds).
To put this into context, a similarly sized plastic container typically weighs just 2.9 ounces (.2 pounds).
The weight doesn’t matter if you’re using them at home, but if you plan to bring them on your commute to work
or send your kids to school with lunch, it will add significant weight to their bags.
Caraway is upfront about its containers not being ideal for storing liquids or soups. It says “Not Intended for Storage of Liquids” on the sticker on the lid.
Despite this warning, my testing has shown that when filled with liquid and turned upside down, they don’t leak. This gives the impression that they can handle liquids well.
But here’s the catch: if the seal isn’t completely secured or if it breaks even slightly, you’re in for a mess. The lid can suddenly pop off, causing the liquid to spill everywhere.
Picture filling one of these containers with a hearty soup for lunch, only to find your bag soaked when you arrive at your destination. It’s a risk that’s not worth taking.
At a glance, you might appreciate the aesthetic of Caraway’s containers, especially with their clear glass lids. This design lets you see the contents from the top, which can be handy.
However, the side walls of the containers are opaque, preventing you from viewing the contents from any other angle.
This becomes problematic when you start stacking these containers in your refrigerator or storing them on higher shelves. Unless you have a bird’s eye view, you won’t be able to identify what’s inside each container.
You’ll need to either remember where you put each food item or remove the containers to check their contents.
As with any glass product, Caraway’s containers have the potential risk of breaking. If you drop one from waist height onto a hard surface, it will likely shatter.
How do I know? I tested the container’s durability by dropping it from about waist-high on my driveway. Sure enough, it completely shattered.
Consider if you’re rushing out the door in the morning with your Caraway container filled with breakfast. A simple stumble or slip could send your container crashing to the ground.
Not only would your meal be lost, but you’d also have to clean up the broken glass.
Finally, the cost of Caraway’s food storage set is a major downside. This set is not the best choice if you’re looking for a cost-effective food storage solution (view the current price on CarawayHome.com and Amazon).
You could buy three or four sets of plastic containers for the cost of one Caraway set.
Yes, with Caraway, you’re getting a set that includes five main containers, four smaller inserts, and three storage organizers. But consider how you plan to use these containers.
Will they be in constant use in your kitchen? Or will they spend most of their time in the cupboard?
While the price reflects the quality of materials and design, it’s still a substantial amount to pay for a product primarily used to store and reheat food.
So, after evaluating all the pros and cons, the question remains: is the Caraway food storage set worth investing in?
If you’re looking for stylish, non-toxic, airtight containers that don’t stain and are easy to clean, and you only plan to use them in your home, Caraway is a great option.
Plus, the storage organizers make it easy to keep your containers tidy. And when they’re easy to find and grab, you’re more likely to use them.
But if you’re looking for something you can use for liquids and take on the go without weighing you down, you’re better off with another brand like Rubbermaid Brilliance (view on Amazon).
If the set is too expensive, you can buy each container individually. So you can start with one or two and add to your collection over time.
- Is Caraway Cookware Worth It? Unbiased Review After 2+ Years
- Caraway Cookware Review: Pros & Cons After 2+ Years (Video)
- Caraway vs. Le Creuset: Which Cookware Is Better?
- HexClad vs. Caraway Cookware: 9 Key Differences
- Made In vs. Caraway Cookware: 11 Key Differences
- Caraway vs. Great Jones: Which Cookware Is Better?
- GreenPan vs. Caraway: Which Ceramic Non-Stick Cookware Is Better?
- Caraway vs. Our Place (Always Pan): Which Cookware Is Better?
- Caraway vs. All-Clad: Which Cookware Is Better?
- Ceramic Cookware Pros and Cons: 21 Things You Need to Know