What’s the difference between Cascade Complete and Platinum dishwasher detergent? Is Platinum worth the higher cost?
In this comparison of Cascade Complete vs. Platinum, I answer these questions.
You’ll learn how these detergents compare in terms of performance, ingredients, scents, price, and more.
I’ll also tell you what the experts at Procter & Gamble (owner of Cascade) have to say about Cascade Complete and Platinum.
Use the links below to navigate the comparison:
- What’s the Difference? The Short Answer
- Difference 1: Ingredients
- Difference 2: Strength
- Difference 3: Formulas
- Difference 4: Scents
- Difference 5: Price
- What Procter & Gamble Says
- Bottom Line: Should You Use Cascade Complete or Platinum?
Cascade Platinum is more expensive than Complete, but it is a stronger, more effective formula containing 50% more active cleaning ingredients.
With Cascade Platinum, you won’t need to pre-wash dishes or soak them in water before placing them in the dishwasher. With Cascade Complete, you may need to soak or scrub stubborn bits of burnt or “sticky” food before putting it through a cycle.
However, an upside of Cascade Complete is that it comes in three different forms: ActionPacs, gel, and powder. Platinum is only sold as an ActionPac.
The ingredients in Cascade Complete and Platinum detergents are similar, but the amounts used in each formula differ.
The basic ingredients in both detergents are:
- Sodium Carbonate (pH balancer)
- Sodium Sulfate (pH balancer)
- Trisodium Dicarboxymethyl Alaninate (active cleaning agent)
- Sodium Carbonate Peroxide (bleach)
- Copolymer Of Acrylic And Sulphonic Acids (shine booster)
- Polyvinyl Alcohol Polymer (soluble film, ActionPacs only)
- Isotridecanol Ethoxylated (active cleaning agent)
- Copolymer Of Acrylic Maleic And Sulphonic Acids (shine booster, Complete only)
- PEG/PPG/Propylheptyl Ether (active cleaning agent)
- Dipropylene Glycol (active cleaning agent)
- Sodium Silicate (active cleaning agent, mineral-based, Complete only)
- Subtilisin (active cleaning agent)
- Glycerin (solvent)
- Amylase Enzyme (active cleaning agent)
- Transitional Metal Catalyst (activator for other ingredients)
On the product labels, ingredients are listed in descending order based on the quantity found in the detergent (i.e., the first listed ingredient is also the one used in the greatest proportion within the formula).
Since the main difference between Cascade Complete and Platinum is the proportion of each ingredient (not the actual ingredients), I’ve created this comparison chart to show these proportions side-by-side.
As you can see in the chart, Cascade Platinum lists active cleaning agents further up on the label, indicating that this detergent includes more of these agents than Cascade Complete.
*Active cleaning agents.
|Ingredients||Cascade Complete||Cascade Platinum|
|*Trisodium Dicarboxymethyl Alaninate||3rd||2nd|
|Sodium Carbonate Peroxide||4th||3rd|
|Copolymer Of Acrylic And Sulphonic Acids||5th||5th|
|Polyvinyl Alcohol Polymer||6th||8th|
|Copolymer Of Acrylic Maleic And Sulphonic Acids||8th||NA|
|Transitional Metal Catalyst||17th||15th|
Cascade is a top-selling dish detergent brand for a reason, and both Platinum and Complete detergents are highly rated. Both are effective –– however, Cascade Platinum is more effective thanks to its greater concentration of cleaning agents.
In fact, Cascade claims that Platinum has 50% more cleaning power (i.e., cleaning ingredients) than Complete.
Here’s what prominent outlets have to say about each option after testing Cascade Complete and Platinum against other top-rated detergents. Both get high marks overall, but Platinum is praised more often.
Cascade Platinum received Excellent ratings from Consumer Reports. They called out its ability to leave dishes sparkling clean and free of water spots. They also mentioned its ability to remove burnt-on food. Cascade Complete was not included in the review.
Good Housekeeping praised both detergents in an article listing the “6 Best Dishwasher Detergents.” Cascade Platinum earned the number one spot, but Cascade Complete was ranked the “best gel dishwasher detergent.” They specifically named the bleach-added version of the original formula.
Taste of Home reviewed Cascade Platinum and gave it the title, “Best [Detergent] for a Spotless Clean.” The reviewers specifically noted how effective this detergent was at removing hard water spots from glassware.
Popular Mechanics ranked Cascade Complete Gel + Oxi at number four on their list of the “10 Best Dishwasher Detergents for a Sparkling Clean Every Time.” Reviewers labeled it the “most effective gel” and noted that it was effective and cost-efficient.
Over at The Spruce, Cascade Complete gel and ActionPacs earned accolades. They were each ranked number one in their category and were praised for removing difficult stains.
TheKitchn.com was a big fan of Cascade Platinum. The reviewers asked plumbers to name their favorite dishwasher detergents, and Cascade Platinum won out over all the other options. Experts noted that these packs help avoid clogs, food poisoning, and poor stain removal problems.
Difference 3: Formulas
Alternatively, Cascade Platinum only comes as a detergent pack.
Both Cascade Complete and Platinum are available in four formulas.
Cascade Complete offers:
- Complete ActionPacs
- Complete Gel
- Complete Gel + Oxy
- Complete Powder
Cascade Platinum offers:
- Platinum ActionPacs
- Platinum ActionPacs + Dishwasher Cleaner
- Platinum ActionPacs + Oxi
- Platinum Power Dry (to speed up drying time)
The “+ OXI” formulas include sodium carbonate peroxide (the main ingredient in OxiClean) to boost cleaning power and stain removal.
Difference 4: Scents
Cascade Complete comes in three scent options:
- Lemon Scent
- Fresh Scent
- Citrus Breeze Scent
The Cascade Platinum comes in two scent options:
- Lemon Scent
- Fresh Scent
Difference 5: Price
Cascade Platinum detergent is about 40% more expensive than Cascade Complete, but the exact price depends on the product type and formula.
For example, the formulas that contain OXI or dishwasher cleaner are typically more expensive than the standard formulas.
When it comes to dishwasher detergent, always compare the cost per load (not the overall cost of the pack/bottle).
To help, I put together the chart below, which shows the current prices of Cascade Complete and Platinum on Amazon.
|Cascade Complete ActionPacs (78 count)||Amazon|
|Cascade Complete ActionPacs (90 count)||Amazon|
|Cascade Complete Gel Detergent (75 ounces)||Amazon|
|Cascade Complete Powder Detergent (155 ounces)||Amazon|
|Cascade Complete +Oxi Gel Detergent (60 ounces)||Amazon|
|Cascade Platinum ActionPacs (62 count)||Amazon|
|Cascade Platinum ActionPacs +OXI (62 count)||Amazon|
|Cascade Platinum ActionPacs (30 count)||Amazon|
|Cascade Platinum ActionPacs with Dishwasher Cleaner (36 count)||Amazon|
What Procter & Gamble Says About Cascade Complete vs. Platinum
She said, “Both are enzyme-based and highly-rated. The biggest difference is that Platinum is the top-performing product. With Platinum, you don’t need to pre-wash dishes or cookware. It contains ingredients that prevent hard-water film. In addition to cleaning your dishes, it also cleans the inside of your dishwasher.” She said, “Complete is slightly cheaper, but the concentration of cleaning ingredients is lower.”
When I asked if Platinum is worth the higher price, she said: “Most customers prefer Platinum. If you don’t want to waste time pre-scrubbing stuck-on food, go with Platinum. In most cases, you won’t need to pre-wash when using Complete, but sometimes you will.”
Bottom Line: Should You Use Cascade Complete or Platinum?
Cascade is a great brand, and choosing between Cascade Complete vs. Platinum comes down to the details. Before I give you my recommendation, let’s recap the differences.
- Cascade Platinum is stronger and more effective thanks to its higher concentration of cleaning agents.
- Cascade Complete comes in three forms (gel, packs, and powder), whereas Platinum is only available as ActionPacs.
- Cascade complete comes in three scents (citrus breeze, fresh scent, and lemon), and Platinum comes in two (fresh scent and lemon).
- Cascade Platinum is about 40% more expensive than Complete.
- The Procter & Gamble product specialist recommends Cascade Platinum over Complete, but both are highly rated and popular among consumers.
Bottom line — Cascade Platinum is more effective and requires less effort (i.e., pre-washing) on your part to get the job done, but Cascade Complete comes in more product formats (ActionPacs, gels, powders) and is cheaper.
If you’re looking to save money or want gel or powder dish detergent, go with Cascade Complete. If you prefer detergent packs, don’t want to pre-wash dishes, and have the budget, Cascade Platinum is worth the money.
If you’re still unsure, try Cascade Complete and see how it works for you. Every dishwasher cleans differently, and if you’re satisfied with the results, there’s no need to spend more on Platinum. But if you find yourself washing “clean” dishes after the cycle completes, Platinum is the better option.
Both are available on Amazon and Walmart.com, where you can compare prices and read dozens of reviews.
- Cascade vs. Finish: Which Dishwasher Detergent Is Better?
- How Much Water Does a Dishwasher Use? (25 Real Examples)
- The Most Reliable Dishwasher Brands (And Brands to Avoid)
- 6 Ways to Fix Standing Water in the Bottom of Your Dishwasher
- Liquid-Plumr vs. Drano: Which Drain Cleaner Is Better?
- How to Fix a Weak Flushing Toilet (8 Simple Solutions)
- Can You Wash Clothes in a Dishwasher? (5 Things to Consider)
- Green Gobbler vs. Drano: Which Drain Cleaner Is Better?
- Dawn Ultra vs. Platinum Dish Soap: What’s the Difference?