Whether it’s a bathtub, stainless steel cookware, or tile floors, Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend help you keep your home’s hard surfaces spotless.
But you might be wondering: which of these two popular cleaners is the better choice? What’s the difference?
In this comparison of Bon Ami vs. Bar Keepers Friend, you’ll learn the differences between these brands’ product offerings, ingredients, instructions, price, and more.
Plus, I reveal which performed the best in my head-to-head cleaning tests.
By the end, you’ll have all the key facts to decide which cleaner is best for you.
Use the links below to navigate the comparison:
- Product Offerings
- How to Use
- Test Results
- What Others Are Saying
- Bottom Line: Should You Use Bon Ami or Bar Keepers Friend?
Bon Ami offers just two products, and both are powdered cleaners (not liquid).
Its original formula has been in use since 1886 and boasts a longstanding reputation for being effective, non-toxic, and reliable for cleaning most messes.
Bon Ami’s newer powder cleanser has a more complex formula, but it’s still non-toxic.
Both products are great for removing hard water scale, rust, tarnish, and scuffs, but the newer formula is more potent and can tackle more difficult messes.
Bar Keepers Friend has a much more extensive collection of cleaners.
Like Bon Ami, Bar Keepers Friend’s basic all-purpose powder cleanser has a long history and has been sold since the 1800s.
The simple formula is effective for most day-to-day cleaning tasks and can remove rust, tarnishes, water spots, hard water scales, and other everyday messes.
Besides the powder cleanser, Bar Keepers Friend offers creams, sprays, liquids, and accessories for cleaning hard surfaces.
Unlike Bon Ami, which only makes two general-purpose powders, Bar Keepers Friend offers specialized products for specific cleaning jobs, including creams, sprays, liquids, and accessories.
For example, Bar Keepers Friend’s Cookware Cleanser and Polish is specifically formulated to remove burnt-on food and deep stains from appliances, utensils, and other kitchen wares, such as stainless steel pots and pans.
One of the most significant differences between Bar Keepers Friend and Bon Ami is the ingredients.
While some cleaning brands hide their formulas in the fine print, both brands are fully transparent about what’s inside their products.
Both list their formulas within the product pages on their websites.
Here’s where you can find the ingredients on BarKeepersFriend.com:
And here’s where you can find them on BonAmi.com:
Below is a concise overview of each brand’s powdered formulas:
Bon Ami 1886 Formula:
- Soap made from tallow (animal or plant fat) and sodium cocoate (acid salts of coconut oil)
- Feldspar (powdered)
Bon Ami Powder Cleanser
- Calcium Carbonate (limestone powder)
- Feldspar (powdered)
- Sodium Carbonate (soda ash)
- Sodium Bicarbonate (baking soda)
- C10-C16 Alkylbenzene Sulfonic Acid (a common chemical surfactant)
Bar Keepers Friend Cleanser
- Mineral Abrasive (mineral powder)
- Oxalic Acid (active cleaning agent)
- Linear Sodium Dodecyl Benzene Sulfonate (Surfactant)
- Water-Softening Agent (removes particles that cause hard water stains/scale)
The key difference between the brands is that Bar Keepers Friend products are more abrasive and potent than Bon Ami.
Also, Bon Ami’s powders feature a finer grit than Bar Keepers Friend, making them safer for use on sensitive surfaces such as non-stick pans or induction cooktops.
Bar Keepers Friend’s main active ingredient is oxalic acid. Although it’s an organic compound found in leafy greens like rhubarb, oxalic acid is highly acidic.
Its acidity makes it an extremely effective cleaner but also makes it harsh on skin and lungs (if you inhale the powder) and toxic if ingested in large quantities.
Bon Ami is non-toxic and contains more natural ingredients. Overall, it’s a gentler formula but still gets the job done.
The difference in Bar Keepers Friend and Bon Ami’s formulas is also reflected in each brand’s Environmental Working Group (EWG) rating.
How to Use
Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend both provide detailed usage information on their websites and packaging. I’ll review the basics here.
To use either of Bon Ami’s powder cleansers, simply spray the target surface with water and sprinkle a moderate amount of powder over it.
Use a wet cloth or paper towel to rub the powder into the surface to form a paste.
Once you’ve cleaned the area, wipe it with a clean towel to remove the paste.
Although some customers state that Bon Ami is effective on non-stick pans and other coated surfaces, the company cautions against it.
Bon Ami powder cleansers are effective on stainless steel, porcelain, enamel, fiberglass, and acrylic surfaces. It’s most commonly used to clean countertops, uncoated glass, toilet bowls, bathroom tile, and grills.
Test your cleanser on a small and inconspicuous area to prevent potential damage to more visible surfaces later.
You’ll follow similar steps when using Bar Keepers Friend powder cleanser.
Wet the surface, sprinkle a liberal amount of powder onto it, and use a damp cloth to rub in the paste. Bar Keepers Friend directs you to wipe away the paste within one minute of application, a caveat that Bon Ami does not include in its instructions.
Since Bar Keepers Friend powders are highly acidic, wear gloves when using them. Since Bon Ami’s formula is gentler, gloves aren’t necessary.
Again, it’s wise to test the cleanser on an inconspicuous area. You can use Bar Keepers Friend on most hard surfaces, but you should NOT use it on gold or silver, polished stone such as marble or granite, colored grout, or lacquered, painted, or mirrored surfaces.
Now that you know about each brand’s offerings, ingredients, and uses, let’s address the top question on your mind: which cleanser works better?
To find out, I conducted a head-to-head test of Bon Ami Powder Cleanser vs. Bar Keepers Friend Powder Cleanser on three different surfaces. I chose a variety of surface types to get a comprehensive understanding of performance.
First, I tested Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend on the bottom of a heavily stained stainless steel pan. The stains and discoloration were so baked into the steel that scrubbing with regular dish soap and water didn’t make any impact (I tried several times).
After sprinkling Bar Keepers Friend on the right side of the pan and scrubbing with water and a sponge, here are the results:
As you can see, Bar Keepers Friend removed the stains completely. I had to use quite a bit of pressure when scrubbing, but it only took a minute to make the pan look new.
I repeated the same process on the left side with Bon Ami and got similar results. Like Bar Keepers Friend, Bon Ami completely removed the stains and restored the pan.
The only difference between the two was that I had to scrub for about twice as long with Bon Ami to get the same result.
I conducted another test on the floor of a porcelain-coated cast iron bathtub. The tub’s surface has a slight texture, which prevents slips but also traps dirt.
Bar Keepers Friend striped the dirt from the tub within seconds, leaving behind a brand new-looking white surface.
In the process, I noticed Bar Keepers Friend not only removed the dirt from the tub but also the green dye from the sponge’s fibers. That shows the potency of the formula.
Bon Ami removed most of the dirt but left behind a slight tint of discoloration. I kept scrubbing for another two minutes and was able to remove it, but the extra effort needed proves that the formula is not as potent as Bar Keepers Friend.
Lastly, I scrubbed dirty tile grout with both products, and I didn’t notice any significant differences in performance. Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend did an excellent job removing the dirt and grime that built up between the tiles.
Overall, I was impressed with the performance of both products. Bar Keepers Friend cleaned the stainless steel pan and porcelain tub more quickly, but both got the job done in the end.
It’s worth noting that the Bar Keepers Friend powder is slightly more clumpy than Bon Ami. I had to shake the bottle to loosen the powder before sprinkling it.
Also, both products have a mild odor, but Bar Keepers Friend’s is more noticeable, especially after you add water and start scrubbing.
Both Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend cleansers are affordable, so price should not be a deciding factor. That said, Bar Keepers Friend tends to be slightly more expensive.
To get an accurate cost comparison, always compare price per ounce rather than overall.
Check out the comparison chart below to see the current prices of Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend on Amazon.
|Bar Keepers Friend Powder Cleanser 12-Ounce (2 Pack)
|Bar Keepers Friend Cookware Cleanser & Polish 12-Ounce (2 Pack)
|Bar Keepers Friend Soft Liquid Cleanser 26-Ounce (2 Pack)
|Bar Keepers Friend MORE Spray + Foam 25.4-Ounce (2 Pack)
|Bar Keepers Friend Cooktop Cleaner 13-Ounce
|Bar Keepers Friend Granite & Stone Cleaner & Polish 25.4-Ounce (2 Pack)
|Bon Ami Powder Cleanser 14-Ounce (2 Pack)
|Bon Ami 1886 Formula 14-Ounce (4 Pack)
What Others Are Saying
Experts have weighed in on both Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend cleansers, and their reviews can help you get an idea of what to expect from either brand.
Let’s review the overall sentiment in the market around these two brands.
The Spruce named Bar Keepers Friend’s Cookware Cleanser & Polish one of the “best stainless steel cleaners.” The experts praised its ability to remove hard water spots and streaks and brighten the steel’s shine better than a dishwasher.
In a separate article about proper laminate floor care, the same blog warned against using cleaners like Bon Ami (or, by extension, Bar Keepers Friend) on laminate floors. The issue is that the abrasive particles in these formulas will dull the laminate.
In its home blog section, Today named Bar Keepers Friend one of the “13 Best Cleaning Products for Your Home.” The reviewers praised Bar Keepers Friend’s powder cleanser for its versatility and ease of use.
Self Magazine chose Bon Ami’s powder cleanser as the best bathroom cleaner in its article “Best Cleaning Products for Tidying Your Space.” The article quoted the founder of a professional cleaning service, who said Bon Ami was amazing at cleaning toilets and tubs.
New York Magazine’s home blog, The Strategist, had even higher praise for Bon Ami’s powder cleanser. It named it number one on its list of the “best all-purpose natural cleaning products for the whole house.” Experts liked its versatility and safe, simple formula.
The New York Times named both Bar Keepers Friend and Bon Ami powders good options for cleaning stuck-on food from stainless steel pots and pans. However, the reviewers added that plain baking soda is their preference, as even gentle cleansers can sometimes damage sensitive surfaces.
Bar Keepers Friend is endorsed by some well-known brands, including All-Clad, Calphalon, Kohler, and Electrolux. These brands recommend Bar Keepers Friend to their customers to remove stubborn stains, rust, and discoloration from their products.
Finally, experts at The Kitchn had high praise for Bon Ami powders. They cited the brand’s longstanding and well-earned reputation for being effective, no-fuss, and reliable for any kitchen cleaning job.
Bottom Line: Should You Use Bon Ami or Bar Keepers Friend?
Now that you know the differences between Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend, it’s time to pick.
But, before I give my recommendation, let’s quickly recap:
- Bon Ami offers just two powdered cleansers, whereas Bar Keepers Friend sells two powders and an extensive lineup of cream, liquid, and spray-type cleaners.
- Bon Ami’s original 1886 formula has just two natural ingredients (soap and feldspar), and both of its products are non-toxic and highly rated by the EWG. Bar Keepers Friend’s powder formulas use oxalic acid, a toxic compound.
- Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend powder cleansers are used the same way. Just wet the target surface and sprinkle the powder –– forming a paste –– before wiping it away.
- Bar Keepers Friend is more potent and cleans tough stains with less effort. But with enough elbow grease, you can get the same results with Bon Ami.
- Bar Keepers Friend is slightly more expensive, but both cleansers are affordable.
- Both brands are highly-rated, earning praise from several media outlets and cleaning experts.
Ultimately, Bon Ami and Bar Keepers Friend are both longstanding brands with excellent reputations. Both brands are highly effective and safe when used according to the instructions.
If you’re dealing with stubborn stains and need the best-performing cleanser, go with Bar Keepers Friend.
If you’re looking for an all-purpose cleaner without harsh chemicals, Bon Ami is a solid choice. Keep in mind; you might need to work a little harder to remove stubborn messes.
- Bar Keepers Friend vs. Comet: What’s the Difference?
- Is Bar Keepers Friend Toxic? Safety Facts You Should Know
- The Pink Stuff vs. Bar Keepers Friend: Test Results Revealed
- How to Clean All-Clad Stainless Steel Cookware (VIDEO)
- 6 Safer Alternatives to Bar Keepers Friend
- Seventh Generation vs. Method: Which Cleaning Products Are Better?
- Fabuloso vs. Pine-Sol: What’s the Difference?
- Ajax vs. Comet: Which Powder Cleaners Are Better?
- Mr. Clean vs. Pine-Sol: What’s the Difference?
- Mr. Clean vs. Lysol: Which Cleaners Are Better?
- What Cleaning Products Contain Ammonia? (19 Examples)
- How to Make 4 Homemade Stain Removers That Actually Work
- Is It Safe to Clean Hardwood Floors With Bleach? (Quick Guide)
- Granite Composite vs. Stainless Steel Sink: Which Is Better?