Mrs. Meyer’s vs. Method: What’s the Difference?

We may earn a fee if you buy via links in this post (at no extra cost to you). Read our Terms & Conditions to learn more.

If you’re shopping for eco-friendly cleaning products but can’t decide between Mrs. Meyer’s and Method, you’ve come to the right place.

In this comparison of Mrs. Meyer’s vs. Method, you’ll learn how these brands compare in terms of product offerings, ingredients, cleaning ability, price, and more.

By the end, you’ll know their differences and similarities and have all the details to decide which brand is right for your home.

Let’s get started.


Use the links below to navigate the comparison:


Product Offerings

Mrs. Meyer’s and Method are two eco-conscious companies offering a variety of non-toxic home and personal care products.

Let’s take a quick look at each brand’s offerings.

Mrs. Meyer’s Product Offerings

Mrs. Meyers Cleaning Products

Mrs. Meyer’s offers a range of useful products, all available in unique scents. Keep in mind that Mrs. Meyer’s doesn’t have unscented products, so if you want something free of fragrances, you’re better off with Method.

Mrs. Meyer’s offers household, multi-surface, glass, kitchen, and bathroom cleaners, including bundles, diluted options, and concentrated formulas so you can get more bang for your buck.

Mrs. Meyer’s also has dish soap and dishwasher detergent pacs. Plus, the company offers large refill packages to cut down on plastic waste.

For hand care, try the hand soap — foaming or non-foaming — lotion, and hand sanitizer.

You’ll also find body lotions, body scrubs, and body washes, all in a variety of scents so that you can find your favorite blend to smell just the way you like.

When it comes to laundry, Mrs. Meyer’s boasts a wide range of products, including detergents, fabric softeners, dryer sheets, and scent boosters. The detergent comes as a liquid or a pac.

They also offer air fresheners or candles in a variety of scents, so you’re sure to find something you love.

Mrs. Meyer’s offers 26 unique scents. Here is a sample:

  • Lavender
  • Bluebell
  • Rose
  • Radish
  • Basil
  • Plum berry
  • Apple
  • Peony
  • Watermelon
  • Snowdrop
  • Iowa pine
  • And more!

Keep in mind that Mrs. Meyer’s products are often scented with synthetic ingredients rather than essential oils.

You can check out the full lineup of Mrs. Meyer’s products on Amazon.

Method Product Offerings

Method Laundry Detergent

In addition to the same range of products offered by Mrs. Meyer’s, Method also offers air fresheners and candles.

The home cleaning products include all-purpose, antibacterial, bathroom, floor, glass, and specialty surface cleaners. These are available in a range of scents and also convenient refills to cut down on plastic waste.

For body hygiene, Method offers body wash, bar soap, body soap, and a specific line for men’s body hygiene, including 2-in-1 shampoo and conditioner and deodorant.

You’ll also find foaming hand wash, gel hand wash, and kitchen gel hand wash along with refills to cut down on plastic waste.

Method can meet all your laundry needs. The company offers detergent pacs, liquid detergent, pump detergents, dryer sheets, fabric softener, fragrances boosters, laundry boosters, and a stain remover. These products come both scented or unscented.

Last, Method offers dish soap and dishwasher pacs, so whether you’re hand-washing or using your dishwasher, you can get your dishes super clean with Method.

As for Method’s scents, here are a few:

  • Lime and sea salt
  • Mint leaf
  • Waterfall
  • Spearmint
  • Eucalyptus mint
  • Orange tangerine
  • Green tea and aloe
  • Coconut water
  • Cedar and cypress
  • Juniper and sage
  • Ginger mango
  • Beach sage
  • Lemon mint
  • And more!

Similar to Mrs. Meyer’s, Method’s fragrances are synthetic. However, they also offer free and clear (unscented) products if you’re looking for a more natural alternative.

Check out the full lineup of Method products on Amazon.

Awards and Accolades

Both brands boast plenty of recognition and praise for their products. They appear on many best-of lists highlighting the top plant-based products. I’ll walk you through some accolades for each brand so you can explore what the experts think.

Multi-Surface Cleaner

On The Spruce’s list of The 8 Best All-Purpose Cleaners, Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day Multi-Surface Everyday Cleaner was ranked as the best green option. It was praised for its cleaning power on nonporous surfaces and for being biodegradable.

Method’s All-Purpose Cleaner was chosen as the best budget option. Reviewers loved it for the variety of scents, affordability, and green chemistry.

Laundry Detergent

The Good Trade awarded first place to Method and second place to Mrs. Meyer’s in its wrap up of 5 Organic Laundry Detergents That Are Safe For Your Family’s Skin.

Method’s liquid detergent was praised for its biodegradable ingredients, ability to brighten laundry, and beautiful scents.

They loved Mrs. Meyer’s liquid detergent for its ultra-concentrated stain-fighting formula with scents that last long after laundry day. 

In The Spruce’s roundup of The 8 Best Green Laundry Detergents, Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day Laundry Detergent won best overall. It was praised for being a family-safe, budget-friendly, and beautifully scented liquid detergent.

Method’s concentrated laundry detergent came in fourth place. The reviewers loved it for its plant-based, biodegradable, and hypoallergenic formula that is tough on stains.

Dishwashing Liquid

In The Strategist’s post The Best Natural Dish Soaps, Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day Lemon Verbena Dish Soap took first place. They loved how gentle it was on the skin.

Method dish soap came in third place in The Spruce’s post about the best environmentally friendly dishwashing liquids. The reviewers loved the ultra-concentrated formula and the handy pump.

Hand Soap

In Bob Vila’s post, The Best Hand Soaps for a Healthy Home, Mrs. Meyer’s Clean Day Liquid Hand Soap took first place, and Method’s Foaming Hand Soap took fifth place.

Mrs. Meyer’s was praised for its refreshing scent, plant-derived ingredients, and moisturizing feel. Method was complimented for its attractive packaging, unique scents, and naturally-derived ingredients.

Ingredients

Both brands practice ingredient transparency — everything in their formulas is listed on the product packaging and the websites. Find the ingredients for Mrs. Meyer’s here and Method’s ingredients here.

While both brands state that their products are plant-based or are derived from plant-derived ingredients, they’re not 100% all-natural or organic.

Mrs. Meyer’s, for example, includes over 140 synthetic ingredients on their list.

Method uses synthetic fragrances rather than essential oils, but the company states that it uses “plant-friendly” ones.

For an unbiased overview of the safety of each brand’s ingredients, check out Mrs. Meyer’s and Method products on EWG.org. You’ll see that the safety grades vary by product, and some ingredients are safer than others.  

Let’s examine each brand’s ingredients in more detail.

Mrs. Meyer’s Ingredients

You can view Mrs. Meyer’s full ingredient list on its website and on the package of each product. You’ll find that the company focuses on plant-based ingredients and essential oils.

Mrs. Meyer's Ingredients
Mrs. Meyer’s Ingredients

While synthetic ingredients are used for fragrances and preservatives, they never contain ammonia, chlorine, parabens, phthalates, formaldehyde, artificial colors, phosphates, or petroleum distillates. Nor are the products ever tested on animals. All Mrs. Meyer’s formulas are cruelty-free and never derived from animal products.

Apart from the ingredients, the packaging is also eco-conscious. Mrs. Meyer’s uses recyclable packaging (but be cautious with the pumps and caps — check with your local authority) made with at least 25% post-consumer plastic.

Method Ingredients

Method’s ingredient information is available on the website. The company doesn’t include a comprehensive list like Mrs. Meyer’s does, but you can find the full list of all the ingredients on the individual products page and each product’s packaging.

Method All-Purpose Cleaner Ingredients on Bottle
Method All-Purpose Cleaner Ingredients on Bottle

The information on their website is more focused on their practices rather than their ingredients. The company takes time to discuss its formulation process and claims that if there’s even the smallest chance an ingredient is unsafe, they won’t include it.

Method encourages third party assessment. The ingredients are evaluated by an independent material research agency, which checks their health and environmental safety. This way, you know that Method isn’t hiding anything.

Method includes a list of ingredients it will never use. These “dirty ingredients” include chlorine bleach, triclosan, phosphates, phthalates, ammonia, and more.

Some people complain that Method uses synthetic dyes and fragrances. Even though the company claims the ones they use are non-toxic and eco-conscious, it’s good to be cautious and use one of the brand’s free and clear (unscented) products if you have sensitive skin.

How does the packaging compare to Mrs. Meyer’s? The bottles are recyclable and also made from recycled plastic. Method also offers refills, which helps customers cut down on plastic packaging.

Design

Both brands have a distinct aesthetic appeal, especially when it comes to the labels. Method features a simple, easy-to-read look.

On the other hand, Mrs. Meyer’s leans towards a busier, more industrious type label, with plenty of words and information.

Both feature bold colors, ensuring the products stand out on both the store shelf and at home.

Method bottles are clear, showing off the bright colors of the product. They have smooth, sleek curves. It’s the type of product you won’t mind leaving out on your countertops. And, because of this, you’ll likely use it more often.

Method All-Purpose Cleaner Packaging

For example, dish soaps have a sleek silhouette and hand soaps are available in various shapes, including triangles, teardrops, ovals, and more.

Method Dish Soap Packaging
Method Dish Soap Packaging

The liquid laundry detergent is available in a geometric hourglass shape, or you can grab the pyramid shape with a handy pump, which helps you measure out the exact amount that you need.

Most of Mrs. Meyer’s products are packaged in a cylinder-shaped bottle.

Mrs. Meyer's Packaging Design

The company utilizes pumps on many of its products. You can also find bigger, bulkier bottles with concentrated formulas. The company’s candles feature big glass jars with prominent ridges around the top.

Overall, both brands have unique and distinct packaging, but Method’s stands out because of its unique shaping and bright colors.

Price

Both brands are relatively inexpensive, but they do tend to cost more than the average cleaning brand. To compare apples-to-apples, look at the cost per fluid ounce rather than the overall price. Or, in the case of laundry detergent, the cost per load.

Also, check out the concentrated formulas, as these tend to last longer. Despite the higher upfront cost, they tend to be cheaper in the long run.

Overall, Method is usually cheaper than Mrs. Meyer’s, but this depends on the product, from where you buy it, and the size and the type of packaging.

Below is a price comparison table so you can check out the current prices.

Prices and images pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

FAQs About Mrs. Meyer’s and Method

Below are answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about Mrs. Meyer’s and Method.

Where Can I Buy the Products?

Purchase Mrs. Meyer’s products on their website, on Amazon, or with other major retailers.

You can’t purchase Method products on the company website, but they are available on Amazon and other major retailers.

Are Mrs. Meyer’s and Method’s Hand Soaps Antibacterial?

Mrs. Meyer’s and Method hand soaps aren’t antibacterial, but if you wash your hands properly for 20 seconds, it removes most germs and bacteria.

Can I Buy Refills of Mrs. Meyer’s and Method Products?

Yes, both brands offer refills to help cut down on plastic waste. Keep the original bottle, and fill it up with a refill pack.

Are the Products Tested on Animals?

Neither brand tests on animals nor uses animal-derived products. Both are certified cruelty free.

What Is Mrs. Meyer’s and Method’s Packaging Made Of?

Mrs. Meyer’s bottles are recyclable and made from at least 25% post-consumer plastic.

Method makes their soap bottles from recycled plastic. The clear bottles are made from 100% post-consumer recycled PET plastic. The opaque bottles are made from recycled HDPE plastic, with the recycled content being at least 25%, sometimes up to 85%. The company continues to find ways to increase this number.

Who Owns Mrs. Meyer’s and Method?

S. C. Johnson & Son owns both Mrs. Meyer’s and Method. In 2008, they bought Caldrea, Co, the makes of Mrs. Meyer’s products. And in 2017, they purchased Method. 

Where Can I Get More Information About These Brands?

Check out Method and Mrs. Meyer’s FAQ pages on their websites. 

Bottom Line: Is Mrs. Meyer’s or Method the Better Choice?

Mrs. Meyers and Method offer a wide range of eco-friendly, award-winning household products.

So which brand is better? Let’s quickly recap the main differences between Mrs. Meyer’s and Method.

  • Both brands are transparent about their ingredients, but Method is more open about their product development practices and 3rd party health and safety testing.
  • Both brands use synthetic fragrances, but some of Mrs. Meyer’s scents are derived from essential oils.
  • All Mrs. Meyer’s products are scented, while Method offers fragrance-free options for those with allergies or sensitive skin.
  • Both offer attractive packaging, but Method has a simpler design that blends in with your decor.
  • Method products are slightly more affordable, but the cost difference varies by product.

The bottom line — both brands offer plant-based household cleaners, detergents, soaps, and personal care products in various scents. Both are focused on your health and the environment, choosing their ingredients carefully and avoiding harsh, harmful chemicals.

Although the differences are minor, Method offers more simple, sleek packaging, fragrance-free options, and a low price.

Mrs. Meyer’s offers 26 wonderful scents, many of which are derived from essential oils.

Both are excellent brands with long track records and thousands of happy customers. 

Since the costs are relatively low, I suggest giving both a try to find out which works best for your home. And, if you’re concerned about the ingredients in a particular product, look it up on EWG.org to assess the risks.

Check the current prices of both brands’ products on Amazon by clicking the links below:

Leave a Comment

Prudent Reviews Footer Logo

Follow us on social:

Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, Prudent Reviews earns fees when you click on links within our articles and make qualifying purchases.

All content on PrudentReviews.com is intended for informational purposes only. The information provided on this website is not intended to be a replacement or substitute for professional advice.

Contact us: [email protected]